Title: How to Prepare for the NYPD Psychological Evaluation (and Avoid a Disqualification)
Meta description: Many capable police candidates are disqualified after the psychological evaluation. A retired NYPD Captain and civil service attorney explains how to prepare for the oral psychological interview.
Every year, qualified candidates pass the written exam, the physical test, and the background investigation, and then receive a Notice of Proposed Disqualification after the psychological evaluation. For many of them it comes as a shock.
I’m a retired NYPD Captain and have spent more than 20 years handling disqualification appeals. The most common mistake I see is candidates treating the psychological process as something they can’t prepare for. You can.
What the psychological evaluation involves
The process generally includes written psychological testing and an oral interview with a psychologist. The oral interview is where many candidates run into trouble. The psychologist reviews your history, your answers on the written tests, and any information from your background investigation. They look at consistency, judgment, how you handle stress and authority, and whether anything in your history needs explaining.
Why capable candidates get disqualified
Inconsistent answers. What you said on the written materials doesn’t match what you say in the interview.
Poorly explained history. Past employment problems, discipline, family conflict, prior counseling, or financial trouble are fine to discuss, but not when you’re caught off guard by the question.
Not knowing your own file. Candidates often forget what they wrote months earlier on the application and questionnaires.
Nerves. Anxiety is easily misread as evasiveness or poor coping skills.
Guessing what the psychologist “wants to hear.” Rehearsed or overly polished answers can raise more concerns than honest ones.
How to prepare
Review everything you’ve submitted. Reread your application, background paperwork, and questionnaires so you can speak about them accurately and consistently.
Identify the sensitive areas in your history. Think through anything that could draw questions and how you can explain it honestly, with context and what you learned.
Practice answering out loud. Saying your answers aloud is very different from thinking them through.
Be truthful. Honesty matters, and a prepared, candid answer is almost always better than an evasive one.
Get an experienced second opinion early. It’s far easier to prepare before the interview than to appeal a disqualification afterward.
Get help before the interview
I offer a one-hour preparation consultation for $250. We go over your history, identify areas of concern, and work through how to approach the oral psychological interview. You can learn more and schedule at PreparingForPolicePsychologicalEvaluation.com.
Already disqualified?
If you’ve already received a Notice of Proposed Disqualification or Notice of Disqualification, deadlines apply, so don’t wait. Contact my office for a free appeals evaluation at 516-641-0881 or visit sheerinlaw.com.
Law Offices of Kevin P. Sheerin, 1000 Fort Salonga Road, Suite 5, Northport, NY 11768. Attorney Advertising. This article is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.
About The Author
Be First to Comment